Plinian volcanic eruptions are notoriously destructive. These very powerful eruptions often
occur after long periods of quiescence and are preceded by relatively short periods of
seismic restiveness. Volcanoes that tend to show this kind of behaviour include Mount
Vesuvius in Italy, Mt. Pinatubo in the Philippines and Mt. St. Helens in the USA.
Professor Donald Dingwell of Ludwig-Maximilians-Universität (LMU) in Munich, together with
Professor Jonathan Castro of the University of Orléans in France, has now been able experimentally
to measure the speed with which molten rock rises during a Plinian eruption. The two scientists
studied rocks that erupted from the volcano Chaitén in Southern Chile in May 2008. Their
experimental analyses revealed that the magma must have ascended from the interior of the volcano
to the surface within a period of only four hours. These results raise the disturbing prospect
that it may not be practically possible to give adequate warning and carry out orderly evacuation
procedures prior to this type of eruption (Nature, 8 October 2009).
First Description of a Plinian Eruption
The first description of a highly explosive volcanic eruption dates from the year 79 AD. In that year,
the Roman author Pliny the Younger observed the famous eruption of Mount Vesuvius, which buried
the city of Pompeii under enormous amounts of ash and pumice. Pliny's description led later
students of volcanology to name eruptions of this type after him.
Plinian volcanoes are
characterized by long periods of quiescence, during which they show very little activity.
Moreover, the rare eruptions are preceded by quite short bursts of tectonic activity, signalled
only by minor earth tremors and increased emission of gas. During the build-up that precedes the
eruption itself, magma rises to the surface within a very brief interval, and is expelled from the
volcano at high pressure in a huge explosion.
Plinian Eruptions at Chaitén
More than a dozen Plinian volcanoes are found in the Andes of South America, yet scientists observed a
typical Plinian eruption there only last year. On May 2nd 2008, the volcano Chaitén in Southern Chile
suddenly began to spew large quantities of ash and rock fragments into the air. The erupted material
eventually gave rise to an ash plume some 20 km high. The town of Chaitén, 10 km away, was covered
by a layer of ash several centimeters thick and had to be evacuated. "This eruption was particularly
noteworthy, because the volcano had been quiescent for over 9000 years", says Professor Donald
Dingwell, Director of the Department of Earth and Environmental Sciences at LMU Munich. "The best
estimates suggest that the last eruption took place in the year 7240 BC."
The Velocity of Rising Magma
Together with the Jonathan Castro from the University of Orléans in France, Dingwell has now been
able to calculate the velocity with which the volcanic material must have risen within the magma
chamber. The researchers collected samples of pumice from the eruption debris, and these were then
subjected to a series of laboratory analyses in Munich, while being heated to a temperature of 825
degrees centigrade at high pressure. After a certain time under these conditions, characteristic
crystalline margins begin to develop around the feldspar crystals in the pumice. Dingwell and Castro
systematically varied the temperature and pressure, and measured the time it took for these crystalline
margins to grow. "The interesting thing is that we found none of these crystalline margins in the
natural samples themselves", reports Dingwell. "From that we can conclude that the material must
have risen so quickly that there was no time for them to form."
Plinian Eruptions are Very Fast
The researchers were surprised by the results of their analyses. Their calculations suggested that
the rock fragments they had collected had ascended from the earth's interior to the crater
floor in less than four hours. To accomplish this, the material must have risen at a rate of about
one meter per second. "This figure is very disturbing, because it implies that a Plinian eruption
can develop with astonishing speed", Dingwell points out. "In such a case, it would be well nigh
impossible to give adequate warning of an impending eruption, in particular if the period of
activity preceding it also happened to be very short." This was precisely what happened at Chaitén.
The inhabitants of the town felt the first perceptible earthquakes on the evening of April 30th.
The first ashfall arrived on the next day, and on May 2nd there was a violent eruption, followed by
the appearance of a huge cloud of ash over the mountain.
"The problem with such short periods of heightened activity is that they may, but do not necessarily,
forecast an eruption", explains Dingwell. "In the case of Chaitén we knew that we were dealing
with a highly explosive volcano. What we did not know was what kind of activity would give notice
of an impending eruption." Normally, patterns of volcanic activity are observed only locally,
for instance by geophysicists who measure seismic waves, or by geochemists who analyse the gases
emitted in the vicinity of a volcano. "Our study is something entirely new and complements the
local observations by using a well-founded experimental and theoretical approach", says Dingwell.
"In our view, this will become an important option in future investigations of the behaviour of volcanoes."
Publication: "Rapid ascent of rhyolitic magma at Chaitén volcano, Chile";
Jonathan M. Castro, Donald B. Dingwell; Nature, 8 October 2009; DOI: 10.1038/nature08458
Contact: Prof. Dr. Donald Bruce Dingwell, Department of Earth and Environmental Sciences ,
Division of Mineralogy, Petrology and Geochemistry, Phone: +49 (0) 89 / 2180-4136
|Pliniain eruption at Mount St. Helens (1980). The largest and most violent of all explosive eruptions, Plinian eruptions send columns of pulverized rock, ash, and gases that rise miles into the atmosphere in a matter of minutes. Mount St. Helens experienced a Plinian eruption following a major flank collapse in 1980. Photo by Austin Post, USGS, May 18, 1980. Enlarge Image
|Simplified plate tectonics cross-section showing how Chaitén volcano is located above a subduction zone formed where the Nazca and South American plates collide. In this subduction zone melting produces magma bodies that rise towards the surface. Image by Geology.com.
Find it on Geology.com
More from Geology.com
|Tumbled Stones are rocks that have been rounded, smoothed and polished in a rock tumbler.
|Topaz is a popular birthstone and the #8 mineral in the Mohs Hardness Scale.
|Know the Rules before removing rocks, fossils or minerals from public or private property.
|Brown Diamonds are growing in popularity and are frequently seen in fashion jewelry.
|Moldavite is a gem material born about 15 million years ago when a pair of asteroids struck Europe.